This past weekend I felt like something with some character and a nice deep, dark porter sounded just right.
Stone Brewing Co’s Smoked Porter:

Stone Brewing Co out of Escondido, CA is quickly becoming one of the most respected craft breweries. With the likes of Arrogant bastard and Ruination IPA, they have virtually cemented their reputation.
This one has a deep, deep dark brown coloring. You can not begin to see through this one. A very nice one finger head that dissipates a little but sticks around for quite a while. Very thick for lacing and sticks wonderfully to the glass.
It has a subtle but distinct smoky aroma to it , assuming they used smoky malts (I should hope so considering the name!) and modest amount of malt and hops to balance it out. I sense some sweetness to it, as if carmalized malt was also used.
Upon landing in my mouth, I instantly tasted the smoky malt that I sensed earlier. The longer it moved around my mouth, the more a coffee undertone came out. Definite taste of hops, although moderate and more balances out the malts, although it does lend a mild amount of bitterness to it.
Overall, this is exactly what I would expect from the geniuses at Stone. I imagine sitting outside on a cool evening with this one, while nursing a nice Cohiba. This one is moderate in ABV, weighing in at around 5.9%. It definitely pairs well with a good pot roast, as well as a creamy desert such as a cheesecake.
Freetail Brewing Co’s 4 Shadow

This one is also a Smoked Porter, brewed by the fine folks at Freetail Brewing Co. Freetail is quickly gaining a reputation locally in San Antonio and in Texas. Now an interesting note, is that the folks at Freetail bill this as a Belgian Smoked Stout. The conundrum is that while at Freetail several patrons referred to this as a Porter. So where’s the confusion? Porters and Stout’s have been intertwined and confused with each other for a while. Both are strong beers and Porters have been thought to be a type of stout.
Freetail owner Scott Meztger marveled at the idea of a Smoked Stout when brewmaster Jason Davis brought it to him “When Jason came to me saying he wanted to brew a smoke beer, I was game. When he said it would be a smoked stout, I was excited. When he said he’d be using our Belgian yeast strain, I was just confused – apparently he had overloaded my ability to process information.”
Scott Googled Belgian Smoked Stouts and came up with nothing. I came up empty as well. This is truly a one-of-a-kind treat.
It pours a very dark brown, with a moderate amount of carbonation providing a decent head that dissipates after a few minutes. Leaving a nice lacing on the glass that sticks around.
Instantly hitting you is a strong smoked scent that instantly soothes, along with very nice and alluring coffee aroma. Hint of spices?
As soon as this one hits your mouth you instantly taste the smokiness that you earlier smelled. Coffee flavoring is abound and a hint chocolate perhaps? Mild hops round out the flavor and the Belgian yeast strain definately comes out, as this has a moderate creaminess to it.
The longer it lingers, the stronger that smokie flavor becomes. Overall, this was a very nice surprise.It weighs in at around 6% ABV and it definitely holds its own against more well know Stouts. I enjoyed this with a well cooked steak and cheesecake for desert. In fact, I’ll be add some of it to the pot roast tomorrow. Hmmmm, 4 Shadow pot roast.. I think we may have something here.
There was one Porter I did not get to, Sierra Nevada’s Porter. I may have to ammend this review later…